Joe Tedesco Posted November 4, 2006 Report Posted November 4, 2006 How long have electrical panelboards been allowed in bathrooms? The same question as it relates to the service disconnecting means?
kurt Posted November 4, 2006 Report Posted November 4, 2006 I guess I'm operating in outer space. I don't think panelboards or service disconnects were ever allowed in bathrooms, at least not for the last 33 years when I've been paying attention to this sort of thing.
Les Posted November 4, 2006 Report Posted November 4, 2006 Kurt, I am sure that is a trick question. I have never known them to be allowed, but my in own personal home that is where it is! After all, I am the AHJ.
Darren Posted November 5, 2006 Report Posted November 5, 2006 Back in 1987 I did a 80,000 sq ft medical office condo building (I was the superintendent). All the doctors and dentists offices that I completed had the electrical panel mounted in the bathroom. Picture a medicine cabinet mounted on the side wall of where the sink is located, that's where the panel was located. I questioned the location, wrote up RFI's and even noted it in the job meeting minutes. It seemed pretty stupid to me.... Every single one was approved by the building & electrical inspectors. Darren
fqp25 Posted November 5, 2006 Report Posted November 5, 2006 I don't know in bathrooms for certain, but in damp and wet areas, cabinets and panels should be of the weatherproof variety; so that moisture and water can't enter and accumulate.
Jim Katen Posted November 5, 2006 Report Posted November 5, 2006 Originally posted by Joe Tedesco How long have electrical panelboards been allowed in bathrooms? The same question as it relates to the service disconnecting means? OK, I'll play. I'm not aware of any rule or code section that prohibits panelboards in bathrooms. As far as I know, they've always been allowed and still are. However, if you want to put breakers in the panelboards, that's a problem. Overcurrent devices haven't been allowed in bathrooms since the '93 edition. As for the service disconnect, if it happens to be an overcurrent device, then it hasn't been allowed in a bathroom since '93. If it's not an overcurrent device, than it's ok to put it in a bathroom. Of course, for the purpose of this discussion, we're talking about bathrooms in dwelling units or guest rooms (or suites) of hotels & motels. The rule doesn't apply to medical office buildings such as the one Darren encountered. Source: 240.24(E) - Jim Katen, Oregon
paul burrell Posted November 5, 2006 Report Posted November 5, 2006 Inspected a condo located in a high rise. The main aervice entrance disconnect cabinet was located in lower parking garage inside wall. Water was leaking down wall both behind and inside service cabinet. By the look of the corrosion it appeared to have been a long term problem. It is amazing to me how complacent the building management and maintenance can be to over look a problem like this. Paul B.
kurt Posted November 5, 2006 Report Posted November 5, 2006 Originally posted by Jim KatenOK, I'll play. I'm not aware of any rule or code section that prohibits panelboards in bathrooms. As far as I know, they've always been allowed and still are. However, if you want to put breakers in the panelboards, that's a problem. Overcurrent devices haven't been allowed in bathrooms since the '93 edition. As for the service disconnect, if it happens to be an overcurrent device, then it hasn't been allowed in a bathroom since '93. If it's not an overcurrent device, than it's ok to put it in a bathroom. Of course, for the purpose of this discussion, we're talking about bathrooms in dwelling units or guest rooms (or suites) of hotels & motels. The rule doesn't apply to medical office buildings such as the one Darren encountered. Source: 240.22(E) - Jim Katen, Oregon Now, that is helpful information. I was overlooking the "breaker/no breaker" aspect of the panelboard; I just assumed we were talking breakers, when in reality, I think w/got what Les said, a trick question practitioner. Didactic catechism's tend to stifle the excitement of learning, and lead to other questions having little to do w/the subject @ hand. Ever had a teacher that would always start the class by plastering the slightly tricky question up on the overhead and never explain it? There's a certain game show aspect to it. Kinda like Alex Trabeck always knowing the answer.
Jim Katen Posted November 5, 2006 Report Posted November 5, 2006 Originally posted by kurt . . . when in reality, I think w/got what Les said, a trick question practitioner. Didactic catechism's tend to stifle the excitement of learning, and lead to other questions having little to do w/the subject @ hand. Ever had a teacher that would always start the class by plastering the slightly tricky question up on the overhead and never explain it? There's a certain game show aspect to it. Kinda like Alex Trabeck always knowing the answer. Personally, I enjoy trick questions. They keep me alert and help to prevent my wheels from running in ruts. - Jim Katen, Oregon
kurt Posted November 6, 2006 Report Posted November 6, 2006 My life is a trick question. I think every home inspection is a trick question. I mean, we have a few hours to look at, oh, a few thousand things, figure out which are the most important, convert our thoughts to a few well chosen coherent sentences, and do it again in the afternoon. Ruts? This sounds wrong, but a little rut here or there sounds mildly attractive on occasion, given my daily flogging in the game of "Guess the House".
fqp25 Posted November 10, 2006 Report Posted November 10, 2006 Well what's the verdict here? Is it a trick question and Joe is holding out on us with some obscurer answer? Is there a little tid-bit of information hidden away in the NEC someplace? The suspense is killing me!!
Chad Fabry Posted November 11, 2006 Report Posted November 11, 2006 Damnit that was funny. I haven't laughed out loud while alone for years. Kurt...you on the Reader's Digest "word o' the day" calendar?
chicago Posted November 15, 2006 Report Posted November 15, 2006 They have always been allowed in the bathroom as long as they are not hooked up.YUK! YUK![:-graduat
Joe Tedesco Posted November 15, 2006 Author Report Posted November 15, 2006 No tricks, just hoping that someone had a copy of the first time the rule was added to the code. PS: Bathrooms are defined in Article 100 and when there is no basin in one the rule for the GFCI's is not applicable.
Jim Katen Posted November 15, 2006 Report Posted November 15, 2006 Originally posted by Joe Tedesco No tricks, just hoping that someone had a copy of the first time the rule was added to the code. PS: Bathrooms are defined in Article 100 and when there is no basin in one the rule for the GFCI's is not applicable. It first appeared in the 1993 edition. - Jim Katen, Oregon
kurt Posted November 16, 2006 Report Posted November 16, 2006 Originally posted by Joe Tedesco PS: Bathrooms are defined in Article 100 and when there is no basin in one the rule for the GFCI's is not applicable. That's useful information, delivered in digestible form. Thanks; I appreciate you sharing your knowledge.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now