acrophi Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Hello, I inspected a home where the main disconnect was in the detached garage. This panel had its own grounding electrode. The panel in the home also had a grounding electrode. Should the panel in the home be seen as a down-stream (sub-panel) and have a floating neutral buss and separate grounds and neutrals. If you are aware of any other issues with this arragnement please feel free to comment. Pictures are included for your review. Thank you in advance for your assistance. Click to Enlarge 62.63 KB Click to Enlarge 67.32 KB
John Kogel Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 I see a 4-wire feeder leaving the main disconnect panel. But I see only a 3-wire feeder entering the bottom of the breaker panel. That is enough for me to call for an electrician to check this out. In my area, that would be wrong, but your local authority might have his own rule book.
hausdok Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Yeah, Power into the main is 4 conductor and leaving is three. Since the main house has more than one branch circuit that buildling must have it's own service grounding conductor and service grounding electrode system but it can only be fed by a 3-wire if there are no other conductive paths between the two structures - no metal fence, no water piping, no concrete sidewalk, no telephone or cable lines. If I got that right, if there is a conductive path between the house and the garage the cable feeding the house from the main disconnect should be a 4-wire. Hunkering down now and preparing to get slammed by Jim K. or Douglas 'cuz I know I've probably got some aspect of this wrong again. ONE TEAM - ONE FIGHT!!! Mike
Darren Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 It's doesn't look like the ground leaving is connected to anything inside the disconnect.
Jim Katen Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Hello, I inspected a home where the main disconnect was in the detached garage. This panel had its own grounding electrode. The panel in the home also had a grounding electrode. Should the panel in the home be seen as a down-stream (sub-panel) and have a floating neutral buss and separate grounds and neutrals. If you are aware of any other issues with this arragnement please feel free to comment. Pictures are included for your review. Thank you in advance for your assistance. Yes, the neutrals should be isolated in the sub panel. It's correct to have separate grounding electrodes at each building. I see a 4-wire cable leaving the disconnect box but I see 3 individual conductors in conduit entering the sub panel. What happens in between? Is the enclosure bonded at the service disconnect? I can't quite tell. The pictures aren't clear enough for me to see much else. In the sub panel, it looks like there's a white wire that should re-identified and, if I were inspecting the panel, I'd look carefully at the arrangement of the black & red wires on all those MW circuits on the left. Also, do I see double tapped neutrals?
Jim Port Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 If I were to guess I would say the SER is feeding the disconnect and the SE is feeding the panel. Maybe someone had some leftover SER and used it instead of SE-U cable.
Marc Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 If I were to guess I would say the SER is feeding the disconnect and the SE is feeding the panel. Maybe someone had some leftover SER and used it instead of SE-U cable. SER: Service Entrance Riser? SE: Type SE cable? SE-U: ? Marc
rkenney Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Originally posted by Marc SE-U: ? Marc Type SE style U has a concentric grounding conductor, with individual strands wrapped around the insulated, current-carrying conductors. Click to Enlarge 17.88 KB
brric Posted February 23, 2013 Report Posted February 23, 2013 Something is amiss. SE cables at the disco, individual conductors at the main lug panel.
Marc Posted February 24, 2013 Report Posted February 24, 2013 Something is amiss. SE cables at the disco, individual conductors at the main lug panel. How do you figure that something is amiss? SE takes power to the disc then individual conductors take it from there to the panel. Marc
brric Posted February 24, 2013 Report Posted February 24, 2013 Something is amiss. SE cables at the disco, individual conductors at the main lug panel. How do you figure that something is amiss? SE takes power to the disc then individual conductors take it from there to the panel. Marc There are no individual conductors in the disco. There is an SER cable and an SE cable.
Jim Port Posted February 24, 2013 Report Posted February 24, 2013 Marc, Both types of cables mentioned in my post are service entrance. SE-U is as shown by Mr. Kenney. SE-R has 3 or more insulated conductors and a non-concentric bare grounding conductors. It is commonly used to feed subpanels.
Garet Posted February 24, 2013 Report Posted February 24, 2013 Yeah, Power into the main is 4 conductor and leaving is three. Since the main house has more than one branch circuit that buildling must have it's own service grounding conductor and service grounding electrode system but it can only be fed by a 3-wire if there are no other conductive paths between the two structures - no metal fence, no water piping, no concrete sidewalk, no telephone or cable lines. If I got that right, if there is a conductive path between the house and the garage the cable feeding the house from the main disconnect should be a 4-wire. Hunkering down now and preparing to get slammed by Jim K. or Douglas 'cuz I know I've probably got some aspect of this wrong again. ONE TEAM - ONE FIGHT!!! Mike Mike, That was the case for many years, but so many electricians got it wrong that newer editions of the NEC (starting in '08 I believe) require a 4-conductor feed to separate buildings in all cases for new work. The exception remains for existing work as long as the criteria you listed are met.
LeePlace Posted February 26, 2013 Report Posted February 26, 2013 I'm sticking with Brric, something is amiss. You have a four conductor cable with a white and a bare conductor leaving the disconnect. There are three black conductors entering the panel board through a pvc conduit.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now