Jump to content

Mess o' ground wires


AHI in AR

Recommended Posts

I don't seen any NMC in my 'hood.......are you allowed to bring it into the panel all bundled up like that?

Not in a flush-mount box like that.

Was it ever allowed, Jim? I look at lots of houses that are 30-40 years old in which all the cables are stuffed through one large hub like that. I always tell my customer about it, but the electrician who comes behind invariably says it grandfathers in.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't seen any NMC in my 'hood.......are you allowed to bring it into the panel all bundled up like that?

Not in a flush-mount box like that.

Was it ever allowed, Jim? I look at lots of houses that are 30-40 years old in which all the cables are stuffed through one large hub like that. I always tell my customer about it, but the electrician who comes behind invariably says it grandfathers in.

Well, first of all, remember that it *is* allowed at the top of a surface mount box if a bunch of conditions are met, including securing the cables before they enter the conduit, making sure the conduit is at least 18" long, and derating the cables as you would for any other bundle if the conduit is more than 24" long.

Aside from that, the electricians you've talked with might be right. The earliest reference I can find is from the 1975 NEC:

373.5© Where cable is used, each cable shall be secured to the cabinet or coutout box. (No exceptions are listed.)

Before '75, I can't find any prohibition against it, except for derating, of course.

I haven't spent much time on this one, but it seems that it was allowed before '75. From '75 till '99 it was flat-out prohibited. And from '99 to the present, the exception for surface-mounted boxes noted above, has been in effect.

If Douglas is following this, he might have more pertinent observations.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't seen any NMC in my 'hood.......are you allowed to bring it into the panel all bundled up like that?

Not in a flush-mount box like that.

Was it ever allowed, Jim? I look at lots of houses that are 30-40 years old in which all the cables are stuffed through one large hub like that. I always tell my customer about it, but the electrician who comes behind invariably says it grandfathers in.

Well, first of all, remember that it *is* allowed at the top of a surface mount box if a bunch of conditions are met, including securing the cables before they enter the conduit, making sure the conduit is at least 18" long, and derating the cables as you would for any other bundle if the conduit is more than 24" long.

Aside from that, the electricians you've talked with might be right. The earliest reference I can find is from the 1975 NEC:

373.5© Where cable is used, each cable shall be secured to the cabinet or coutout box. (No exceptions are listed.)

Before '75, I can't find any prohibition against it, except for derating, of course.

I haven't spent much time on this one, but it seems that it was allowed before '75. From '75 till '99 it was flat-out prohibited. And from '99 to the present, the exception for surface-mounted boxes noted above, has been in effect.

If Douglas is following this, he might have more pertinent observations.

As always, you rock.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...